Skip navigation Jump to main navigation Jump to main navigation

New York State’s Determined Leadership in Understanding and Regulating Artificial Intelligence

By Steven Cohen, Ph.D., Director of the M.S. in Sustainability Management program, School of Professional Studies

While the transactional scientific illiterate in the White House looks at Artificial Intelligence (AI) as still another way to personally profit from his exalted position, the State of New York is working overtime to understand, slow down, and regulate AI. All of this must start with developing a deeper understanding of how AI works, its potential benefits and costs, and methods of ensuring human control in the public interest. There are a set of assumptions now underlying the financial and political reality of AI which may or may not be true. The first is that the most advanced AI will require ever-expanding brute computing power necessitating the generation of huge amounts of electricity. The second is that we are in a competition with China to develop the most sophisticated forms of AI. The need for computing power may not grow as predicted as scientists, aided by AI, develop more energy-efficient methods of analysis and model construction. The national competition with China assumes that methods of AI development will be proprietary and kept secret by those developing these technologies. Perhaps, but perhaps not. Scientists like to share findings and learn from each other and aren’t great at secrecy. In any case, we need to know more than we now do to understand these potential costs.

New York’s effort began in 2024 with the start of a statewide consortium of public and private university-based AI researchers, and it expanded last week with Governor Hochul’s announcement establishing:

“…a first-of-its-kind statewide effort to advance artificial intelligence science and safety – the New York Center for AI Responsibility and Research based at State University of New York’s (SUNY) Binghamton University. The Center will bring together unprecedented academic expertise to advance AI safety research, accelerate scientific discovery, and independently test advanced AI systems for safety and security. “While the federal government fails to act, New York is leading the way on AI safety and holding big tech accountable,” Governor Hochul said. “The stakes are too high to simply take AI companies at their word. That's why we are bringing together our world-class researchers and the computing power of Empire AI to independently test powerful AI systems, understand their risks and put that knowledge to work protecting New Yorkers…Greg Morrisett of Cornell Tech and Jeannette Wing of Columbia University, two internationally recognized leaders in computer science and cybersecurity, will lead the Center as interim co-directors. At the Governor’s direction, they will bring together more than 80 leading scientists from colleges and research institutions across New York State with expertise in AI safety, security and computer science. The Center, based at Binghamton University, will convene researchers to address AI safety issues and ensure New York is pushing forward not only AI innovation, but also security. The Center is supported by the advanced computing power of Empire AI, Governor Hochul’s $500 million public-private initiative to drive AI research for public good.” https://www.dfs.ny.gov/node/449846

In addition to this effort to understand AI, the state is taking several steps to regulate its development. According to the New York State Department of Financial Services: 

“…the new Office of Digital Innovation, Governance, Integrity, and Trust (DIGIT) launched its online portal for large frontier AI developers to register with New York State by January 1, 2027. Under the RAISE Act, all frontier AI developers operating in New York are subject to safety and transparency requirements, with additional obligations for large frontier developers. Large frontier developers are required to register through the newly released RAISE Portal by January 1, 2027. Beginning in January, large frontier developers will also be required to publish safety frameworks on their websites, and all frontier developers will be required to report critical safety incidents and publish model transparency reports. Additionally, DIGIT published a new website outlining requirements for frontier AI developers operating in the state.” 

The state is also managing its own use of AI. State Technology Law §103-e requires the Office of Information Technology Services to maintain an inventory of state-agency AI systems that directly affect public safety, welfare, or rights. The first is required to be posted on New York’s Open Data website on December 30, 2026. There are a number of efforts underway that are starting the complex effort of providing guardrails around AI use. These efforts include the AI research and registration mentioned above, as well as efforts to regulate AI safety, AI “companions,” deepfakes, and performer rights. There is also a state effort to project the impact of AI on our workforce.

One impact of AI development already known is the environmental, energy, and community impact of large data centers. The State of New York is currently implementing a one-year moratorium on data center development while it studies and develops rules governing data center siting. During the moratorium, the state is studying and will propose rules to govern data center impacts on:

  • Electricity demand and grid reliability.
  • The cost of transmission upgrades.
  • Water use and quality.
  • Air quality, including emissions from on-site generators.
  • Noise and light pollution.
  • Disadvantaged communities.
  • Compatibility with New York’s climate requirements.

These rules will have an impact on AI in New York State, but their limits are clear. Many AI companies operate outside of New York and will remain unregulated, and courts may find some of the state’s rules to be an effort to regulate interstate commerce, which the U.S. Constitution limits to the federal government. Still, states are called “laboratories of democracy” for a reason. They have sovereign powers in our federal system. They can try out programs without the commitment of a national effort. In fact, several of the social welfare innovations of the New Deal were begun in New York when Franklin Roosevelt was Governor. 

Perhaps most importantly, the investment in AI research that will not be owned and controlled by private, for-profit companies can provide an independent voice for developing guardrails based on knowledge rather than fear and myth. AI scares people because it is powerful and poorly understood. I do not believe technological development can be stopped, but do believe we can establish norms and rules that govern its use. We have seen that with nuclear and biological weapons and nuclear power. Their regulation is far from comprehensive, but instances when we’ve seen despots like Putin threaten damage have far exceeded actual weapons use. 

But a government that advocates self-regulation by the group of self-centered, emotionally stunted tech bros developing AI is inviting disaster. The scientists who invented the atomic bomb were terrified of its power and did everything they could to ensure that the public understood the danger. We are seeing similar warnings from AI scientists, but unlike the atomic energy scientists who worked for our military during a world war fighting fascism, AI scientists work for private, for-profit firms, more interested in making money than promoting public good. 

The Trump administration has damaged the U.S. economy and our national security with tariffs, attacks on science, attacks on hard-working immigrants, politicizing the military, and eliminating regulations that protect human and environmental health. AI will be a powerful force in economic and technological innovation. Properly governed, it can be a source of great good. Unregulated, its impact could be destructive beyond imagination. With a Democratic Congress that hopefully resists revenge and perhaps with the help of some Republicans more interested in good governance than political combat, we could develop a consensus around reasonable regulation of Artificial Intelligence. If not, we will need to hope that New York and other states take action to understand and regulate this important new technology.

 

Views and opinions expressed here are those of the authors, and do not necessarily reflect the official position of Columbia School of Professional Studies or Columbia University.


About the Program

The Columbia University M.S. in Sustainability Management program offered by the School of Professional Studies in partnership with the Climate School provides students cutting-edge policy and management tools they can use to help public and private organizations and governments address environmental impacts and risks, pollution control, and remediation to achieve sustainability. The program is customized for working professionals and is offered as both a full- and part-time course of study.

Authors

Steve Cohen

Steven Cohen, Ph.D.

Senior Vice Dean, School of Professional Studies; Professor in the Practice of Public Affairs, School of International and Public Affairs

Related News

All News
All News