Skip navigation Jump to main navigation

Anatomy of the 2026 Blunami

By Gregory Wawro, professor of political science and program director of the M.S. in Political Analytics at Columbia University School of Professional Studies

While seven races remain to be called, the 2026 US midterms were an historic election which saw Democrats win unusually large majorities in both the House and Senate. Pre-election, all signs pointed to a wave in favor of Democrats, but what was unclear in the run-up to November 3 was just how big the wave would be.

But how do we even define a wave? How do we measure it? Saying an election is or is not a wave is not terribly helpful from a political analytics perspective. How do we distinguish a red riptide from a blunami? This question is critically important for our understanding of how elections work in the U.S. and how well democratic representation is working. 

One approach is to drill down to individual races and consider expectations about competitiveness. One standard take on U.S. House races is that there are very few competitive races. Partisan polarization, helped along by gerrymandering, has created a terrain where many districts see overwhelming support for one party over the other. Incumbency has long been an important factor in reducing competitiveness, where those holding seats secure their positions (perhaps by actually serving their constituents well) in ways that discourage serious challenges. Most challengers in House elections fail to marshal enough resources—especially campaign contributions—to mount serious opposition to incumbents. But incumbents still lose, and many voluntarily retire if they perceive that they will face a tough reelection fight with a quality challenger.

The competitiveness of races is assessed by various organizations based on a number of factors, including electoral history of the district, demographics and quality of the challenger (if any has emerged). A good place to start is with those ratings. The Cook Political Report ranking system categorizes races as Solid Democratic (not competitive), Likely Democratic (some competition but the Democrat is likely to prevail), Lean Democratic (more competitive, but the Democrat is slightly favored), and Democratic Tossup (the seat is currently held by the Democrats, but there's at least a 50-50 chance that is will flip to Republicans).  The mirror image of the rankings applies to Republicans.

My conceptualization of a wave involves parties winning the seats they are expected to but also making inroads into the other parties’ territory. For example, for 2026, I expected Democrats to win all of their likely and lean seats, more than half of the toss-ups, and pick off a few likely and lean Republican seats. Refining this further, they would win the seats they were expected to win by wide margins, while Republicans would struggle more in that category.

With the help of ChatGPT, I created this animation to help display how the wave unfolded in real time. It takes the Cook rankings from the last update prior to Election Day and shows, over the course of the night, how the wave formed and grew as races were called by the Associated Press (the AP data is available here). I use the standard red and blue colors for the parties and to make this more digestible, display columns only for Likely Democratic to Likely Republican. Solid races appear in the bar at the top. 

A few things to pay attention to: The signs of a blue wave appear early in the evening as soon as the AP starts calling races (the earliest poll closings were 6 p.m.). Democrats jump out to an early and huge lead in Solid races. By midnight, Democrats are winning handily in their Likely/Lean races, and a hint that the swell will be bigger than expected can be seen with two Democratic pickups in the Lean Republican category and one in the Likely Republican category. The AP called the majority for the House at 1:24 a.m. It was pretty clear by the time polls closed on the West Coast that Democrats would be in control of the chamber.

The animation is an especially effective way to see how the momentum was all on the Democrats’ side and how the wave built over the course of the night. As the first races are called, the Democrats jump out to a big lead in keeping their Solid/Likely seats and starting to win toss-up and leaning races. By midnight, the magnitude of the wave has started to emerge, with Democrats picking up 12 seats formerly held by Republicans without losing any of their own seats. These gains have started to include Lean and Likely Republican seats. By the time race calls slow to a trickle (around 4 a.m. on November 4), Democrats have not lost a single seat, even in the toss-up category and have made significant inroads into Republican territory, leading seat pickups by an astonishing score of 23-0. At the time of writing, this lead would expand to 44-3, with the GOP picking up only one seat in each of the Lean, Likely, and solid Republican categories.

Democrats won every single toss-up seat. That alone would make this a blunami. In a strong wave, we would have expected them to win more than half, perhaps two-thirds. Winning every single one, along with seven Lean Republican and five Likely Republican races, and even one Solid Republican race, makes this one of the strongest waves in U.S. history.

A final note: This visualization actually understates the magnitude of the wave as I’ve conceptualized it here. The Cook Political Report updates its ratings over the course of an election cycle. In 2026, the movement was almost entirely in the Democrats' direction, even in the face of redistricting efforts meant to strengthen Republicans. If we used, for example, the ratings published in April, Democrats would have picked up a whopping 16 Solid Republican seats.

Views and opinions expressed here are those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect the official position of Columbia University School of Professional Studies or Columbia University.


About the Program

The Columbia University M.S. in Political Analytics program provides students quantitative skills in an explicitly political context, facilitating crosswalk with nontechnical professionals and decision-makers—and empowers students to become decision-makers themselves.

The 36-credit program is available part-time and full-time, on-campus, and online. Learn more about the program here. 

For general information and admissions questions, please call 212-854-9666 or email politicalanalytics [[at]] sps [[dot]] columbia [[dot]] edu (politicalanalytics[at]sps[dot]columbia[dot]edu).


Sign Up for the SPS Features Newsletter

 

Authors

Related News

All News
Kiran Bhujle

The Vendor Is the Outage

All News